Deeply flattered, Mr. Harper. Really.

They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. If so, we’re feeling awfully flattered today.

Here’s an ad we created with the Manitoba NDP during the 2011 provincial election.

And here’s an ad the federal Conservatives have just released, four years later:

There’s a reason they’re using our spot, and that’s because it was very effective in Manitoba. It defined Hugh McFadyen and turned the tide at a time when the NDP was vying for a fourth term and trailing the Conservatives in the polls. It spoke to people’s real concerns about Mr. McFadyen and his agenda of cuts and privatization. And it did it in a light way that people could connect with. That, in turn, set the stage for the Manitoba NDP’s come-from-behind victory.

Whether the Conservative ad will be as effective is another question. We believe every campaign is unique, with its own challenges and opportunities. Copying even a highly successful ad (cough, blush) from a previous election isn’t necessarily a smart approach.

Their best point is that Mr. Trudeau isn’t ready for the job; the more Canadians look at him ahead of the fall election, the more likely it is they’ll conclude he doesn’t have the experience they want in a Prime Minister.

The problem for the Conservatives (and the Liberals) is that there’s a better choice who is ready. Tom Mulcair has the experience, intelligence and understanding of Canadian families to be their Prime Minister. And after the Quebec breakthrough in 2011, and Rachel Notley’s victory this month in Alberta, Tom’s resume may well be the one that makes it through.

Tags: , , ,

3 Responses to “Deeply flattered, Mr. Harper. Really.”

  1. […] heart was really in it, note how the writers didn’t even bother to write the ad. No, they just ripped off a 2011 ad produced by the Manitoba NDP. The only way they could do that and think they […]

  2. […] “They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. If so, we’re feeling awfully flattered today,” read a blog post on the NOW Group’s website. […]

  3. […] Group was somewhat gracious, headlining their blog post about the appropriation “Deeply flattered, Mr. Harper. […]

Leave a Reply